Formal Consumer Complaint Regarding CPB China
正文:Dear Shiseido Group Headquarters and Clé de Peau Beauté Team,
I am a relatively new CPB customer whose interest in the brand grew following the appointment of Ms. Liu Shishi as its brand ambassador. This prompted me to make purchases from CPB, and I am able to provide proof of purchase upon request.
I am writing to formally lodge a consumer complaint regarding the developments following the brand’s apology statement issued on 14 November 2026.
1. The characterisation of the speaker as an individual “not involved in brand-related business operations” is inconsistent with publicly available facts.
In its statement, the brand attributed the controversial remarks to “certain individuals not involved in brand-related business operations”.
However, Ms. Nakahara Anri’s publicly stated position is Vice President of External Affairs for Shiseido China. In 2023, she was awarded the Shanghai Magnolia Silver Award. She has also represented Shiseido in its dealings with government authorities and attended official events over an extended period.
Characterising a senior executive within the Group’s management structure as someone not involved in brand-related business operations directly contradicts these publicly available facts. This description inevitably undermines the credibility of the brand’s statement and raises legitimate questions about the accuracy and accountability of its internal management and external communications processes.
2. The brand issued an apology to Mr. Tan Jianci but did not reaffirm Ms. Liu Shishi’s rightful status as CPB’s brand ambassador with comparable clarity.
The brand’s owned records have already confirmed that Ms. Liu Shishi was announced as its brand ambassador in October 2026.
Nevertheless, following the publication of the statement, certain public narratives have portrayed Ms. Liu as the source of the controversy. There have even been attempts to discredit her contributions as the brand’s ambassador. Her studio has reportedly completed evidence preservation in relation to these matters and intends to pursue legal action.
The way in which the statement was handled has resulted in a clear imbalance: one party received an apology, while the other received no official clarification of comparable prominence or authority.
3. The market performance following Ms. Liu Shishi’s appointment in October 2026 is supported by publicly available data.
Since Ms. Liu was announced as CPB’s brand ambassador in October 2026, her appointment has brought the brand significant benefits in several respects.
First, Ms. Liu’s positive public image and the distinctive elegance she embodies as a representative of Eastern beauty have generated substantial positive exposure for CPB and enhanced public perception of the brand.
Second, her appointment helped drive purchases among a considerable number of high-net-worth consumers. CPB products also saw significant improvements in their rankings across major e-commerce platforms, while the brand recorded encouraging year-on-year growth in e-commerce sales in October.
I fully acknowledge that a brand’s sales performance cannot be attributed entirely to any single ambassador. Nevertheless, CPB should not allow Ms. Liu Shishi, who has fulfilled her contractual obligations and made significant contributions to the brand, to be unfairly held responsible for matters beyond her control or subjected to unwarranted public criticism and personal attacks.
Such a situation is fundamentally inconsistent with the values and brand culture that CPB represents. As a consumer, I find this deeply troubling and extremely disappointing. It has also shaken my confidence in whether I should continue supporting the brand.
My formal requests as a CPB consumer are as follows:
1. Publicly acknowledge Ms. Liu Shishi’s outstanding contributions to the brand, and express its gratitude to Ms. Liu and to the consumers who chose to purchase CPB products in support of her.
2. Issue an official clarification of Ms. Nakahara Anri’s position and role within Shiseido China, and publicly refute the false claims and rumours surrounding the alleged “sales attribution” issue and related matters.
3. Remove defamatory, abusive and misleading content targeting Ms. Liu Shishi from the comment and repost sections of CPB’s official social media accounts, and issue a sincere public apology to Ms. Liu and the wider consumer community.
I sincerely hope that Shiseido Group Headquarters and the CPB brand team will treat this complaint with the seriousness it deserves and provide a substantive response to the concerns and requests outlined above, rather than issuing a generic or standardised customer service reply.
Yours faithfully,
A Loyal CPB Consumer Supporting Ms. Liu Shishi